Detailed Silvercar Rental Review: A Nice Experience, But is it Worth the Premium?

10

Join over 5,000 people who are subscribed to receive a once daily email with all of our posts. Never miss out! Click here to subscribe.
Learn how to maximize your points & miles! Join Our Facebook Group!

Silvercar Rental Review

Note: New users who sign-up for Silvercar using a referral link earn $25 after completing their first rental. The referrer also earns $25. If you find this review helpful then I ask that you consider using referral code SCOOMER when signing up. Thanks!

Silvercar Rental Review & Experience

Today’s post comes from PDX Deals Guy who has previously written about using the Amex Fine Hotels & Resorts program in Las VegasTicket Reselling and how to earn up to 2.625% with the Bank Americard Travel Visa. You can follow him on Twitter and look for the latest deals on his website.

I had my first two experiences renting from Silvercar last month and wanted to pass along some details. The first rental was a one-day rental from Chicago (O’Hare) in early December, followed by a three-day rental in Denver in mid-December. As I’ll show later, I was able to take advantage of the new renter $25 bonus for both rentals (my wife was the renter on the second trip), but I wasn’t able to fully maximize the coupons do to the length of my rental.

Picking Up the Car

As with any fairly new company worth its salt, Silvercar relies heavily upon technology to improve efficiency and hopefully improve the user experience. Where that first really shows up is before you even pick up your car. As soon as your flight lands, you can fire up the Silvercar app on your smartphone and hit the “pick me up” button. The app will give you directions on where to proceed, which will vary depending on the airport. It will also provide you with contact information, via phone or text message, to stay in communication with Silvercar throughout your rental.

I preferred the pick up experience in Chicago, as I was promptly picked up right at the airport curb by an employee in a Silvercar. She was very friendly and started showing me the features of the car, as well as answering all my questions. (I was surprised to learn that they have between 80-100 cars in Chicago, depending on the season. Not bad scale for a fairly recent startup!) She drove me to a fairly close-by location where I got to choose from one of 6 or so identical cars. (Tough choice! Although she did point me to the newest cars and mine had less than 3000 miles.)

Silvercar Rental Review

In Denver the experience wasn’t quite as great. Silvercar contracts at DEN with an off-site parking lot operator (Canopy Airport Parking). This means waiting for a shuttle bus, and the experience simply felt less refined than in Chicago (and there was a bit of a wait at drop-off too). I guess the main takeaway is that the experience is going to vary from city to city.

Once you get to your car, the employee has you scan your car with your smartphone app. This unlocks the car and begins a simple rental process. You go through a few quick steps on the phone, which are effectively a slimmed down version of a typical car rental experience, such as accepting or waiving insurance coverage.

The Car and Rental Features

Silvercar Rental Review

Silvercar is simple and fantastic when it comes the the car. You will get a new model, silver Audi A4. But where the rental really shines is in the list of included (“free”) features, which I found to be mostly great or at least as-advertised:

Navigation/GPS – Probably the nicest thing about this is having the Silvercar location pre-programmed into the navigation favorites to make returning the car really simple. That said, as a heavy Google Maps and Waze user, I found that I did not like Audi’s directions compared to my apps, especially in Chicago.

Free Wi-Fi – In case the employee forgets to tell you, the password is “SILVERCAR” (you can always text or call them to ask if you forget). That said, once you get connected, it was a pretty disappointing experience for me in both cities. The car has a 3G connection (not sure which carrier) that was next to worthless. I was soon off wi-fi and relying upon my phone’s LTE data plan.

Satellite Radio (and Bluetooth) – Not much to say about the satellite radio, other than it’s nice standard feature. The sound system was good, and connecting my smartphone to the car via bluetooth for both phone calls and media/entertainment features (a separate process for both) was fairly straightforward and worked well.

Silvercar Rental Review

Fair Toll Tracking – This was very nice, especially in Chicago. Silvercar has a toll payment device installed in all of its cars and does not charge any markup on the tolls. In fact, you get the benefit of lower fees on such toll devices, compared to the “cash” rate most tourists usually pay.

Fair Fuel Plan – This is another nice feature. You may optionally choose to return the car with the fuel gauge at any level. Silvercar fills the tank and only charges you a fair local rate (not some big markup per gallon), plus a flat $5 fee (unless you return the tank full). In my experiences, both the amount of gas I was charged for and the price-per-gallon seemed very fair.

All Wheel Drive – This is the one feature not really highlighted on Silvercar’s own website that I think can be a big differentiator. While I was fortunate to avoid bad weather in Chicago, our Denver trip was to take advantage of our newfound Hyatt Diamond status and a visit to the Park Hyatt Beaver Creek resort in Vail. Having AWD turned out to be a very nice feature driving in the mountains and it also came in handy during a snowstorm during our return to Denver on departure day.

Silvercar Rental Review

The Economics

While my first rental was only a one-day rental and didn’t take advantage of the 2-day $75 off deal, I did find the rate to be reasonable, especially using the 15% off code and after the $25 sign-up bonus I got using Shawn’s referral code SCOOMER. While it doesn’t show on my email receipt, I received an email within minutes of returning my rental telling me that I had received a $25 PayPal payment as a first-time renter. Here is my one-day rental receipt, which includes a 1 day charge, a number of tolls, fuel and all taxes. All of those items are itemized on the receipt you receive.

Silvercar Rental Review
This includes a 1 day rental along with fuel and all taxes/surcharges.

On the second rental, I was able to take advantage of both the $25 first-time renter incentive (my wife’s first rental!) and the $75 off the 2-day rental promotion. While I had to pay full price for the third day of the rental, I still found the overall rate to be very competitive, especially for getting an AWD rental vehicle in Denver.

Silvercar Rental Review
This includes 3 days, fuel and all taxes/surcharges.

One final note related to pricing. As I always do with car rentals, I waived all insurance coverage and paid for the rental entirely with my Chase Sapphire Preferred card, given its primary insurance coverage. Before the trips I checked the Sapphire Preferred’s auto rental documentation, and based upon my understanding of said documentation, an Audi A4 is NOT considered a luxury vehicle that would be disqualified from coverage.

Conclusion

While the pickup process may vary between airports, I found both rentals to be very good overall experiences. Certainly without the discounts, Silvercar is a bit of a premium experience, but it may be worth it on occasion. That said, without getting into a detailed competitive pricing breakdown, there were both cheaper and more expensive options from the traditional major car rental companies in both Chicago and Denver. Thus, for me, Silvercar has definitely earned a spot for consideration in the car rental equation on my upcoming trips. I likely won’t pay a big premium if discounts aren’t available in the future, but if the price difference is within a small margin, or if a rental will make good use of a standard Silvercar feature (such as AWD in snowy weather), I’ll look forward to my next experience.

Please share your Silvercar experiences or questions in the comments!


This post may contain referral, affiliate or sponsor links that provide Miles to Memories compensation. Thank you for your support.

10 COMMENTS

  1. Looking forward to my first Silvercar rental in DEN next month for a ski trip. 4 days in an AWD A4 for under $200 with the new sign up + 75 off deal. Compare that to $600-$1500(!) for an AWD vehicle from any other renter in Denver. Holy Smokes!!

    • That was a great part of my Denver rental. As I mentioned (above), I’m kind of surprised that Silvercar doesn’t highlight the AWD feature more on their website. I’ve heard rumor that Silvercar has some Audi SUV’s in some markets (like Denver – to allow for more space for ski equipment), but I didn’t see any (nor did I see it as an option on their website – although it’s possible they were sold out on the dates I searched).

  2. Do you have to do anything special to use the primary rental’s insurance on the Chase Sapphire card? Meaning, do you have to contact Chase first before renting, or anything of the sort

    • My understanding of the terms (I encourage you to read them and/or call Chase) is that all you need to do is put the entire charge on the Sapphire card and decline all other coverage.

  3. Chase Sapphire auto insurance does not cover Relay Rides which is now Turo, did you call the Sapphire number to double check about Silvercar?

    • I did not. But please update us if you do. I assumed that Silvercar was the same as any other traditional car rental agency. Whereas Turo is more of a ride-sharing/car-rental hybrid.

  4. When registering at Silvercar, it asks for coverage information. What do you enter for Insurance Carrier/Policy # if you plan on using Chase Sapphire’s primary rental coverage?

    • Sorry, Antonio, but I honestly cannot remember. I don’t recall being forced to put in that info. But maybe I did (if I wasn’t forced to, then I didn’t). Regardless, at the time your rent the car, it give you the option to waive their coverage.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here